I had great results from my Optima red top. It lasted 10 years in my YJ, initially as a DD, and later as a primarily offroad toy. The only reason it stopped working was a wiring issue randomly kicked on my lights and completely drained it dead. It will take a charge now but it won't hold it for more than a couple days if it sits. Pretty sure I killed it. My buddy had the same issue with a used optima he got from Interstate. Crappy radio that came with his CJ would kick on while the Jeep was off and kill his battery.
For price, I bought my replacement yellow top from Advance using a coupon code from Slickdeals for $50 off of $150. IIRC I was out the door for $147
For price, I bought my replacement yellow top from Advance using a coupon code from Slickdeals for $50 off of $150. IIRC I was out the door for $147